During a live interview on Florida’s Voice Radio, attorney general James Uthmeier stated that his office will not appeal convictions stemming from the state’s 2018 ban on bump stocks and certain trigger enhancements. He described the statute as “overly broad” and asserted that it conflicts with recent Second Amendment interpretations by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Legal reasoning behind abandoning the ban

Uthmeier referenced the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision that struck down the federal bump-stock prohibition, emphasizing that the Court held such devices do not turn a semiautomatic rifle into a machine gun because the trigger must be released for each shot. He argued that Florida’s law similarly bans an entire class of firearm accessories without a historical analog, violating the plain-text protection of “bearable arms” under the Second Amendment. The Attorney General’s office released a formal opinion saying the ban “imposes a categorical prohibition on an entire class of firearm components that can increase a semiautomatic weapon’s rate of fire.”

Background of the 2018 gun-control package

The 2018 legislation emerged after the tragic February 14 mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, which claimed 17 lives, including 14 children. Lawmakers combined three major measures: a ban on bump stocks, raising the minimum age to purchase rifles from 18 to 21, and a “red-flag” law allowing courts to temporarily seize weapons from individuals deemed dangerous. Funding for school safety and a “guardian” program to arm selected staff members were also included. While the bill passed with bipartisan support, it split both parties, with some Republicans opposing the gun-control provisions and several Democratic legislators objecting to arming school personnel.

Political ramifications and the AG’s broader agenda

Uthmeier linked his decision to the recent midterm elections, noting that “we survived in one of the toughest, if not THE toughest, election nights Republicans have seen in history because we HAVE pushed common sense.” He highlighted record low crime rates and signaled that Florida will continue to lead “multi-state legal challenges on constitutional and regulatory issues.” Beyond the bump-stock debate, the Attorney General cited a 500% increase in fentanyl prosecutions over the past 18 months, which he says contributed to a 60% decline in fentanyl-related deaths and an 80% drop in encounters. He also mentioned ongoing coordination with newly elected House Speaker Sam Garrison on AI-related consumer protections and a multistate lawsuit against OpenAI.

Investigation into foreign influence

During the same interview, Uthmeier announced subpoenas directed at the Democratic Socialists of America to determine whether the organization received illicit foreign funding or travel benefits from countries such as China and Cuba. He warned that any nonprofit receiving “monetary support, fundraising, anything of value” from foreign governments would be violating Florida law.

The Attorney General’s stance on the bump-stock ban does not repeal the law; it remains on the books until the legislature acts or a court declares it invalid. However, by refusing to defend the statute on appeal, Uthmeier signals a shift in how Florida will approach gun-rights litigation moving forward.